Why is John so different from Matthew, Mark and Luke?
In John, Jesus clears the temple at the start of his ministry, not the end. He goes to Jerusalem several times. There are long speeches and almost no parables. Why?
In John, Jesus clears the temple at the start of his ministry, not the end. He goes to Jerusalem several times. There are long speeches and almost no parables. Why?
You've noticed the main differences: John places the temple scene early (2:13–22), mentions several Passovers (2:13, 6:4, 11:55), and gives Jesus long discourses and "I am" sayings instead of short parables. Explanations range widely: - John knew the others and wrote to supplement them. This view goes back to the early church, which called John the "spiritual" gospel. - John drew on an independent tradition, which in places (like the multiple trips to Jerusalem) may be historically better informed. - John arranged material theologically more than chronologically — the temple scene at the beginning frames the whole ministry. Reading one Gospel all the way through, then John all the way through, is the best way to feel the difference.